The Evolution of the Tunisian Ennahda Idea from the Movement to the Formation of the Government

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Student, Political Thought Department, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Political Science Department, Payam Noor University-Tehran, Iran

3 Associate Professor, Political Science Department, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

10.30484/jii.2023.3162.1083

Abstract

The Muslim Brotherhood movement can be considered the most important, coherent, and ideological political movement among Sunnis. While the religious principles and ideological-political ideals of this movement can be traced back to its late founder, Hassan al-Banna, changes in policy, intellectual foundations, and executive approaches have become evident over time due to the movement's spread to other countries and environmental and social influences. These changes have been particularly noticeable in the Tunisian branch of the Brotherhood led by Rachid Ghannouchi. At the 10th conference of Ennahda, secular Islam was openly discussed, a departure from the movement's founding principles. This shift can be attributed to inefficiencies in the executive sphere, as Ennahda struggled to achieve success in the political arena and deviated from its core principles to pursue its goals. This article aims to explore the intellectual transformation of Ennahda, shedding light on the main components, contexts of change, and factors influencing the observed transformation. By employing a descriptive-analytical method based on library and field information and data from interviews, the article seeks to answer how Ennahda's approaches, ideological developments, and performance have evolved from a movement to a governing entity, and in which areas these changes have been most pronounced. The findings suggest that Ennahda has adopted an approach of epistemological minimalism, peaceful tendencies, and realistic performance in the political realm to navigate a middle ground with modernity, marking the first step in its ideological transformation.

Keywords


  • Ibrahim, Muhammad and others(2012), The Muslim Brotherhood of Egypt,Translated by Javad Asghari, Published by Noor,Tehran, First Edition.[in Persian [
  • Ibrahimnia, Hussein, (2006), Islamic Movements in Tunisia, in the Encyclopedia of Islamic Movements, Volume 4, Institute for Cultural and Social Studies of the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology.[in Persian [
  • Ibrahim Mottaqi and others, (2014), The Role of Regional Actors in the Radicalization of Social Forces in the Middle East, Quarterly Journal of World Politics, Volume 3, Issue 2, Summer.
  • Ibrahim, Muhammad and others, (2006), The Muslim Brotherhood of Egypt, Translated by Noor Thought-Makers Studies, Tehran. First edition
  • Ajili, Hadi, Mehdi Beiki, (2016), Analysis of the Political Transformation of the Islamist Movement of the Muslim Brotherhood in Tunisia (Al-Nahda), Quarterly Journal of Political Research in the Islamic World, Year 6, Issue 1, Spring
  • Soltaninejad, Mohammad,(2014), Ennahda Party in Tunisia: Political Centrism and Internal Divisions, Tehran: Institute for Thought-Forming Studies of Noor, Issue 130.
  • Seyed Ahmadi, Seyed Mohammad,(2018) Transformation in the Thought and Practice of the Muslim Brotherhood (Egypt and Tunisia); From Movement to State, Tehran, Islamic Azad University, PhD thesis.
  • John L. Esposito, (2010), Contemporary Islamic Movements (Islam and Democracy), Nay Publishing House, Tehran.
  • Royoran, Hossein (2016), Renaissance and Intellectual Renewal in the Muslim Brotherhood Movement, Islamic Culture Magazine, November, No. 40
  • Ali Akbar Alikhani, (2003), Islam and Government in the Thought of Rashid Ghannouchi, Middle East Studies, No. 33.
  • Moradi, Majid, (2018), Theory of the State in the Political Thought of Hassan al-Banna, Political Science Jourrnal, Qom: Baqir al-Uloom University, No. 19, Autumn.
  • Mosli, Ahmad, (2012), Discourses of New Fundamentalism on Civil Society, Pluralism and Democracy, Translated by: Mohammad Taqi Delforuz, Tehran: Farhang Javid .[in Persian [
  • Nabavi, Abdul Amir (2005), Political Islam in Egypt; Transition to Political Minimalism, Quarterly Journal of Middle East Studies, Year 12, Spring Issue 41
  • Nabavi, Abdul Amir, (2016), Revision of the Renaissance: The Beginning of a Historical Stage in the Life of Islamism, Institute for Strategic Studies of the Middle East, Middle East Translation Journal, Issue 2

Internet sources:

  • Lotus Rugler, The Islamic Renaissance Movement, translated by Manouchehr Amirpour, June 2012, available at:http://www.goethe.de/ges/phi/prj/ffs/the/a97/fa9514045.htm
  • Majid Moradi Rudpashti, History and Discourse of Political Islam in Tunisia, Thought Club, 15/11/2018 Retrieved from: http://www.mapms.blogfa.com/page/p807

https://www.khabaronline.ir/

  • Eskandari, Mehdi, Renaissance Tunisia; From "Movement" to "Party", Tabyin Center, 26 October 2016, available at:
  • http://www.tabyincenter.ir/qadim/index.php/menu-examples/child-items-6/1395070607
  • Ghannouchi: Rashid, Ennahda does not compromise on its principles, Al-Alam, 13/1/2013, available at:
  • http://fa.alalam.ir/news/1459876
  • Sheikh Rashid Al-Ghannoushi's Political Thought, 22/3/2011, available at:
  • http://www.afran.ir/modules/smartsection/item.php?itemid=1483
  • Sayyed Afaghi, Sayyed Hadi 2014, "Intellectual Developments of Ghannouchi and the Ennahda Party in Tunisia", Institute for Future Studies of the Islamic World, Visit Report: https://iiwfs.com/%D8%AA%D8%AD%D9%88%D9%84%D8%A7%
  • Lotus Rugler, The Islamic Renaissance Movement, translated by Manouchehr Amirpour, June 2012, available at:http://www.goethe.de/ges/phi/prj/ffs/the/a97/fa9514045.htm
  • Haji Karim Jabbari, Mohammad Reza, (2011), The Future of Secularism in Tunisia,  November 2   , Saturday, available at: http://irdiplomacy.ir/fa/news/17311
  • Fars News Agency, 28 Mehr 2012, available at: https://www.farsnews.com/news/8911111001
  • Afran Research Institute, The Muslim Brotherhood Movement in Egypt, 2/10/1390. Visit: http://www.afran.ir/modules/publisher/categor
  • Ghannouchi: Rashed, Ennahda does not compromise on its principles, Al-Alam, 1993, page 108, available at: https://fa.alalam.ir/news/1459876/%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%B4%D8%AF
  • Fadel Al-Baladi, 2014, specialized interview, Badr Magazine, Tehran, Al-Waqt website, visit: http://alwaght.net/fa/Workgroup/581
  • Karim Mortazavi specialized interview, Badr Magazine, 2013, Tunisia expert, Al-Waqt website, visit: http://alwaght.net/fa

       Arabic sources:

  • Al-Harmasi, Abdul-Latif (1985), The Islamic Movement in Tunisia, Bayram Publishing, Legal Filing, Second Edition
  • Abu Zakaria, Yahya, (2003), The Islamic Movement in Tunisia from Al-Thawlib to Ghannouchi, E Publishing in July.
  • Abu Samar, Muhammad, (2005), The Hamas Movement: Its Roots and Views, Translated by Noor, Tehran,Thought-Forming Studies Institute.
  • Ghannouchi, Rashid, (2003), Public Freedoms in the Islamic State, Arab Unity Studies Center. Vol. 1, Beirut, Lebanon.

       English sources: